So what app has the worst icon? I know a lot of them suck...but here is my least favorite:<br><br><img src=http://homepage.mac.com/bganey/.Pictures/dmx.jpg><br><br>One of my favorite:<br><br><img src=http://homepage.mac.com/bganey/.Pictures/mj.jpg><br><br>

no...I say these are the worst! <br><br><br>My stuff for sale.

I hate the iCal icon, mainly because the damn thing's always stuck on July 17th <br><br>

Well, may I recommend this!<br><br><br><br>

Any particular reason you don't like the DW logo? I think it's nice. It's easy to recognize in the dock when the icons all get nice and tiny. <br><br>Except for Safari and iTunes, I'm not nuts about most of the Apple ones. Don't like Mail and I don't like HD icons provided by Apple. URL Manager Pro has got to be about the ugliest app logo I've ever seen though. I even went in and edited the resources so I wouldn't have to look at it:<br><br><br><br>When it gets really small, all that detail crap just turns into nothing. Too many colors, shapes and crap going on.<br><br><pre>** sometimes you win, and sometimes you learn **</pre><p>

I agree...I like the DW logo too.<br><br>OK..now THIS is the worst one!<br><br>and this one"<br><br><br>My stuff for sale.

To me, the DW icon is too cartoonish, and is unbecoming of a pro app that costs $400. <br><br>

I agree with ya, square- anything that is easy to see in the dock scores points with me too...<br><br>

Hey...COOL! I am gonna go get it. <br><br>

In my professional designer's opinion, I think ICONS should be somewhat cartoonish. Think international signage and you have the same thing that icons should be. Stripped down pictograms that are immediately distinguishable and easy to read from near or far (in the case of OS HCI that would be large or small). <br><br>The new developer guidelines that Apple has where they say to make them more realistic and photographic is not a good guideline.<br><br>Besides, that dreamweaver "d" icon is only cartoonish because it imitates the Apple Aqua button interface. I think it's consistent and fits the OS well. Just my 2¢<br><br><pre>** sometimes you win, and sometimes you learn **</pre><p>