#598399 - 07/13/1308:44 PMRe: Great Bill Maher "New Rule"
[Re: AusMac]
six_of_one
Pool Bar
Registered: 04/19/02
Posts: 4472
Loc: Alexandria, VA
Originally Posted By: AusMac
Jobs are jobs.
finding work is .. finding work.
While I'd debate that jobs are all equal, I would agree that for a desperate unemployed citizen any job should be better than not earning anything at all. The question there is wether that really is true in the real world and if so, how many are unable to find *any* job at all due to the presence of illegal workers?
There is a segment of the population that seem to think that illegal aliens will take jobs from citizens,
I also wonder if those who think that this is not so would still think that if they thought their job was in jeopardy
Unlikely scenario, since most of those jobs are ones most US citizens wouldn't deign to have in the first place ...
While it's probably true that a Mexican is not very likely to steal a Corporate Lawyer's Job, you're not taking into account that someone trying to support a family by picking fruit might feel a bit more pressured, esp. if that's the only work to be found for a hundred miles of his home.
...doesn't even have to be an illegal alien... in some cases the migrant pickers might even be a college student on Walk-About that your boss hires for the duration of the YEARLY HARVEST willing to work for a $1 less than you can manage on.
While I'd debate that jobs are all equal, I would agree that for a desperate unemployed citizen any job should be better than not earning anything at all. The question there is wether that really is true in the real world and if so, how many are unable to find *any* job at all due to the presence of illegal workers?
You do not live in the real world if you have to ask the question.
_________________________
“His throw went absolutely nowhere near where it was going.” ~ Richie Benaud.
AP: Private prisons profit from illegal immigrants (AP) MIAMI - The U.S. is locking up more illegal immigrants than ever, generating lucrative profits for the nation's largest prison companies, and an Associated Press review shows the businesses have spent tens of millions of dollars lobbying lawmakers and contributing to campaigns.
By putting prisoners to work and paying them competitive wages, many private companies are reducing prison costs for the government by withholding earnings for taxes, room and board, Family support, and victim's compensation. Such employment also gives prisoners the skills and work experience that will prepare them for the job market when they are released.
Private business has become increasingly interested in prison labor during the past decade. Prompted by state and federal measures lifting restrictions to private sector use of prison labor, some eleven states contract out the work of an estimated 1,000 convicts. Over twenty firms, ranging from small businesses to multinational corporations, provide jobs for inmates. For instance, Best Western International, Inc, a major hotel chain, employs over thirty Arizona prison workers to operate the hotel's telephone reservation system. Since the Best Western program began in 1981, inmates have paid $182,000 in taxes, contributed over $187,000 to the state for room and board, and paid at least $112,000 in Family support. Similarly, Trans World Airlines, Inc. hires young offenders from the Ventura Center Training School in California to handle over the phone flight reservations. The inmates have paid a total of $13,000 in taxes, $15,000 for room and board, and $11,000 to victims for restitution.
In most cases, the state correctional system provides the working facility for the private firm. The firm manages and trains the inmates and releases their earnings to the care of the state. The wage rates, in most instances, are negotiated between the state agency and the private firm. .:etc:.
#598405 - 07/13/1310:14 PMRe: Great Bill Maher "New Rule"
[Re: Celandine]
six_of_one
Pool Bar
Registered: 04/19/02
Posts: 4472
Loc: Alexandria, VA
Originally Posted By: Celandine
While it's probably true that a Mexican is not very likely to steal a Corporate Lawyer's Job, you're not taking into account that someone trying to support a family by picking fruit might feel a bit more pressured, esp. if that's the only work to be found for a hundred miles of his home.
...doesn't even have to be an illegal alien... in some cases the migrant pickers might even be a college student on Walk-About that your boss hires for the duration of the YEARLY HARVEST willing to work for a $1 less than you can manage on.
True, but I'm under the impression that the percentage of out-of-work citizens actually competing for those types of jobs is relatively small vs. the overall pool of Americans looking for work. Certainly some segments of job-seekers are impacted more than others, but the studies I've read/heard about show the immigrant workforce, both legal and illegal, actually has a net neutral or slightly positive effect on the job market and economy overall ... and that legalizing undocumented workers would provide additional net benefits ...
While it's probably true that a Mexican is not very likely to steal a Corporate Lawyer's Job, you're not taking into account that someone trying to support a family by picking fruit might feel a bit more pressured, esp. if that's the only work to be found for a hundred miles of his home.
...doesn't even have to be an illegal alien... in some cases the migrant pickers might even be a college student on Walk-About that your boss hires for the duration of the YEARLY HARVEST willing to work for a $1 less than you can manage on.
True, but I'm under the impression that the percentage of out-of-work citizens actually competing for those types of jobs is relatively small vs. the overall pool of Americans looking for work. Certainly some segments of job-seekers are impacted more than others, but the studies I've read/heard about show the immigrant workforce, both legal and illegal, actually has a net neutral or slightly positive effect on the job market and economy overall ... and that legalizing undocumented workers would provide additional net benefits ...
You seem to be overlooking the fact that unemployment in this "economic down-turn" is not restricted to The US.
Overall figures do not necessarily affect the individual. Unless of course they become legal.
Then there is such as this.. An anecdotal case where farmers were overheard talking about how immigration had busted an onion harvest with helicopters and road vehicles converging on the spot.. "who is going to pick the onions unless they are illegals?" "mechanical harvesting is not viable?" "no way. It all has to be done by hand."
This is in a land where all illegals have to risk drowning in a leaky boat to get here.
Edited by AusMac (07/13/1310:34 PM)
_________________________
“His throw went absolutely nowhere near where it was going.” ~ Richie Benaud.
True, but I'm under the impression that the percentage of out-of-work citizens actually competing for those types of jobs is relatively small vs. the overall pool of Americans looking for work. Certainly some segments of job-seekers are impacted more than others, but the studies I've read/heard about show the immigrant workforce, both legal and illegal, actually has a net neutral or slightly positive effect on the job market and economy overall ... and that legalizing undocumented workers would provide additional net benefits ...
However, I take (and agree with) your point. even though my sig. other has been out of work for the past 2 years, it had nothing to do with anyone other than his flint-hearted (ex)boss. Ted suffered a heart attack, and the bassturd called him back early (thus ending his disability) only to lay him off a week later so he could cancel his insurance too.
That said, Ted was so highly skilled in his field that he set the Industry ISO Standards. But pushing 60 with a pre-existing condition has become a death sentence.
Yeah.. I know, "Life Sux, then you die."
Anyway, I believe there's enough work to go around in America, if the bassturds would only stop rigging the game.
Why is everybody blaming Our Southern Cousins (just as I consider Canadians our Northern Cousins) for a lack of jobs (INDUSTRY) that they are NOT Responsible For?
Ted's Job was ultimately shipped to CHINA! The people should be pisssed that "PINHEAD INC." was responsible for putting us into Crushing Debt to finance TWO Unnecessary Wars "on the dime" for which Pres, Obama is now forced to tap-dance around to appease the country that owns us to keep them from calling in the loans?
Now the unemployed are being manipulated into blaming Mexico for their dire straits? WTF?
Even the greedy SOBs that used Tax Loopholes by putting Americans out of work by opening Sweat-Shops South of the Border grew fat while the workers starved, and still had to take their chances by crossing the borders...
"Rigged Game" indeed
The only justice so far is that Ted's millionaire ex-boss who outsourced his specialized skill overseas is in the process of losing his family business due to the Law Suits rolling in every day from American's suffering from the inferior materials being implanted in their bodies.
#598414 - 07/13/1311:36 PMRe: Great Bill Maher "New Rule"
[Re: AusMac]
six_of_one
Pool Bar
Registered: 04/19/02
Posts: 4472
Loc: Alexandria, VA
Originally Posted By: AusMac
Originally Posted By: six_of_one
Originally Posted By: AusMac
Jobs are jobs.
finding work is .. finding work.
While I'd debate that jobs are all equal, I would agree that for a desperate unemployed citizen any job should be better than not earning anything at all. The question there is wether that really is true in the real world and if so, how many are unable to find *any* job at all due to the presence of illegal workers?
You do not live in the real world if you have to ask the question.
Hmmm ... most of the articles and reports regarding illegal workers I've seen (some here, here, and here) show a net neutral if not slight beneficial impact to the overall workforce and economy. Which isn't to say some segments aren't impacted (employment for males w/o a high school diploma seem to be hardest hit, for example), but the overall economy and employment appear to benefit somewhat ...
... And lest you think the answer so obvious the question needn't even be asked, even this Fox News article feels the need to present two sides of the debate ...
Previous Topic
Index
