Decided to finally replace my old Linksys WRT54G. I bought that back in about 2003 when 802.11g was pretty fresh for home use. It still works, but has gotten a little flaky (requiring more resets) and I'd like to upgrade to 802.11n for my more recent hardware.
I picked up the Airport extreme without doing very much research. In computer years its decades ahead of my old one and... its made by Apple, it must be good!
First thing I notice is that there is no support for dynamic DNS updating. Lame, my linksys did that in 2003. Oh well, whatever, I'll run the simple daemon from dyndns.org.
Then the real garbage begins. Port forwarding on my linksys was always easy. Add the port, hit update and it was always open and available. In recent years, I just said "screw it" and hit the DMZ button (opening all ports) and was done with it. I've never encountered any security concerns.
I can't for the life of me get ports to open with this thing.
It appears pretty self-explanatory. In the advanced tab of networking there is a NAT setup. You hit "+" to add a new service and there is a place for public and private TCP and UDP and a place for your private IP of the device you want forwarded to. Great. Too bad no matter what port I choose, nothing opens up. For example, I use Timbuktu to access my machine from work. It requires only port 407. I put that in all the fields, and add the local IP of my machine...nothing. And websites like this that check for open ports show it is still closed. Same for ftp on port 21... heck I can't even get regular apple sharing to work. (and yes, the sharing for both ftp and file sharing is on in the system preferences)
I tried the AEBS version of DMZ too. I set my home desktop to have a static IP by DHCP reservation (10.0.1.253 is the default) using its MAC address. No problem there, but when I hit the button to have that be the default device for NAT I get nothing on any ports. No way to connect to this network externally.
I can't believe this device is really this dysfunctional? What could I be doing wrong, this just shouldn't be that hard to do.
I don't know why you're having those problems. Something is awry. What is the external IP address that the Extreme is grabbing? Just post the first number, ex 74.x.x.x. I'm looking to see if your modem is also doing NAT, many of the new modems do that now, adding another layer of complication to port mapping.
I have not liked the airport bases until the last couple of years or so. They are up to par now, and have great range.
Loc: Pinellas Park, Florida
My AP Express is 10.x.x.x. My dLink router is 69.x.x.x (I changed it from the default 192.168.x.x). I don't do port forwarding, etc, since I don't have a need to. The Express is used solely for iTunes streaming to my stereo in the living room. The dLink is for internet and for my wife's wireless connection.
Ahhh gotcha. The 68 one is the one that is listed by the AEBS in its parent tab for manual setup. The linksys WRT54G used to set local IPs starting with 192, but as Bozo points out, the AEBS uses 10.0.x.x.
So, it doesn't look like the modem is performing routing functions.
• When I first plugged in the router I had everything turned off (modem too, but it has a battery). Upon starting it up, I got nothing but a blinking amber light and the status indicated I had no connection. I shut everything down again and unplugged the cable company's coaxial cable for several minutes allowing the modem to fully reset before repowering the router. That did it, so I think the modem has been reset completely.
• Apple's firewall (in system preferences) is off, and has never been used by me.
• Yeah, I hit update after every tinker I do. Interesting though, each time it says to wait while "AE restarts", or something like that. But, only after certain modifications does it actually restart (you get the amber light again, etc.). Most of the time the Airport utility just hangs a bit, but there is no physical change in the status light of the airport itself.
I'm at work for a couple more hours, or I would post pics too. But yeah, its just like that, except in the case of FTP or Timbuktu its a single number in those address fields. I would be happy as a clam to just open up all the damn ports DMZ style if I could, but that was a bust too.
I'll try the factory reset again when I get home, as well as another complete modem/router/computer reboot. Only two possibilities here. Either Apple's hardware is flaky, in which I'm disappointed with them. Or, I'm doing something wrong which is still Apple's fault because this is supposed to be easier than a damn Cisco device!
Loc: Pinellas Park, Florida
As a note, I had to directly connect my Mini (ehternet cable) to my Express to do its initial setup. It did "complain" (yellow light) that it did not have an internet connection for several days until AP Utility finally detected the error state and allowed me to tell it to ignore the "error." It has had a nice green glow since.
Xplain's use of MacNews, AppleCentral and AppleExpo are not affiliated with Apple, Inc. MacTech is a registered trademark of Xplain Corporation. AppleCentral, MacNews, Xplain, "The journal of Apple technology", Apple Expo, Explain It, MacDev, MacDev-1, THINK Reference, NetProfessional, MacTech Central, MacTech Domains, MacForge, and the MacTutorMan are trademarks or service marks of Xplain Corp. Sprocket is a registered trademark of eSprocket Corp. Other trademarks and copyrights appearing in this printing or software remain the property of their respective holders.
All contents are Copyright 1984-2010 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.