I don't think that its a HD issue. Seems like it could be a power issue maybe, or like Whitlock said RAM possibly. I would mess around with some things to try and pin point it a little further.
"Fix it 'til it Breaks."

Jacob - EiC & Director of Technology
Mac Pro Quad 2.66 - 4GB RAM
160 GB SATA RAID 1 - 650 GB Storage
Quad 19" Widescreen LCDs
Accessorized to the Hilt